Mingtiandi

Asia real estate and outbound investment news

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
Sign Up / Login Logout

Lost your password?
Register
Forgotten Password
Cancel

Register For This Site

A password will be e-mailed to you.

  • Capital Markets
  • Events
    • Join the Mingtiandi Proptech Forum 2021
      • Asia Proptech 2021: COVID-19 Accelerates a Trend
      • Panel Talk: Tech Adoption in Logistics Real Estate
    • Promote Your Brand with the Mingtiandi Proptech Forum 2021
    • 2021 Mingtiandi Event Calendar
    • More Events
  • MTD TV
  • People
  • Logistics
  • Asia Outbound
  • Retail
  • Design & Construction
  • Research & Policy
  • Advertise

Shenzhen Developer Agrees to Pay $1M Fine in California Bribery Scandal

2020/10/11 by Elizabeth Kerr Leave a Comment

Luxe City Center Hotel

Shenzhen Hazens bought a hotel full of trouble in SoCal

China’s surge of overseas real estate acquisitions of the past decade continues to reap negative returns for the country’s developers with the merely unprofitable now giving way to a million dollar fine in one Los Angeles case.

A unit of mainland developer Shenzhen Hazens has agreed to pay $1.05 million as part of a deal to avoid possible criminal charges and remove itself from an investigation into bribery of LA municipal officials, the US Department of Justice announced on Thursday.

Yardi General 2

The official statement noted that, “A three-year non-prosecution agreement (NPA) with Jia Yuan USA Co., Inc. is the latest development in the ongoing investigation into a wide-ranging “pay-to-play” scheme in which developers bribed Los Angeles city officials to secure official acts to benefit their real estate projects.

Hazens had set up Jia Yuan USA to acquire and redevelop the Los Angeles Luxe City Center Hotel in 2014, the second of multiple projects it acquired in Los Angeles with the developer having enlisted the help of a corrupt city official by providing concert tickets, campaign contributions to political campaigns and other illicit benefits.

City Council Pay to Play Scheme

Under the agreement with the Department of Justice, Jia Yuan will pay the monetary penalty within two weeks of the October 5 deal, and will continue cooperating with the FBI in its ongoing investigation into bribery, fraud and illicit campaign contributions by foreign entities and other disguised players.

jose huizar

Jose Huizar goes on trial next year on 34 counts

The government probe is aimed at uncovering a pay to play scheme operated by corrupt city officials and Jia Yuan’s parent company Hazens must also abide by the non-prosecution agreement.

The focus of the investigation at this point appears to be former city councilman Jose Huizar, who is scheduled to face trial next June on 34 counts including racketeering, wire fraud, bribery, money laundering and other charges. Those alleged crimes are related to soliciting payments from property developers in return for favourable consideration of building permit applications and other procedures.

In a statement of facts which was part of the non-prosecution agreement, Jia Yuan admitted to providing Huizar with Katy Perry concert tickets in exchange for intervention on a compliance issue at a Hazens hotel, as well as to having employees make campaign contributions to political candidates at the behest of a foreign national prohibited from participating in American elections,

Beyond those admissions, Jia Yuan also agreed as part of its deal to avoid prosecution that it had, at the behest of a foreign national, provided in-kind contributions to political candidates via reduced cost events at the Luxe.

The company further admitted, that in order to ensure Huizar’s favourable vote on city motions beneficial to the Luxe project, it had facilitated introductions that resulted in contracts that in turn paid indirect bribes to the city official. The company also confessed that it had partially subsidised a trip to China for Huizar and his family organised by consultant George Chiang, who has already been cooperating with authorities concerning his role funneling contributions to the then-councilman.

Staying Out of Trouble

According to a statement by the Department of Justice,  the government opted out of prosecuting Jia Yuan for three years, on the condition that it refrain from illegal conduct, because the firm accepted responsibility for its actions, and immediately terminated Chiang.

Proptech Registration Column

Chiang is scheduled to be sentenced next February after pleading guilty to one Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) charge in connection with his work with Hazens.

The government also noted Jia Yuan’s improved compliance procedures and cooperation with investigators as part of the rationale for its decision, including providing records to investigators which were out of reach in China and making its mainland-based chairman available for interviews.

“The NPA does not preclude or limit the investigation or prosecution of individuals, including any current or former Jia Yuan officer, employee or agent,” added the Department of Justice in its statement.

Rain in Southern California

Hazens acquired the Luxe City Center six years ago for $105 million and immediately began work on a plan to transform the property across from the LA Live complex into a $700 million mixed-use development.

Proptech Registration Column

Approved by the LA City Council in 2017, Hazens has yet to break ground, and the project ran into further trouble in June when the city’s planning director began revoking “all of the Project’s conditional use approvals,” according to Los Angeles Magazine.

At the time the little-known Shenzehn developer was part of a wave of Chinese capital flowing into southern California real estate which included Shanghai Greenland Group in mid-2013 announcing that it had purchased the $1 billion Metropolis mixed-use project in downtown Los Angeles.

Beijing-based Oceanwide also made a big LA splash in 2014, when it acquired the Fig Central project in downtown Los Angeles, renaming the project across the street from the Staples Center as Oceanwide Plaza and calling the acquisition a $200 million deal. That project has since stalled after the company was sued for non-payment by its suppliers.

Hazens’ hometown competitors at Shenzhen New World had begun investing in hotel projects in southern California in 2010 when it purchased the Sheraton Universal Hotel in Universal City for $90 million, the same year that it purchased what is now the LA Grand Hotel on Figueroa Street from GE Capital for $63 million.

In January of last year, Greenland Group, Oceanwide and Shenzhen New World, along with Hazens” were all named “parties of interest” in an FBI search warrant which was part of a Department of Justice investigation of the Huizar bribery scandal.

There has been no word of further investigation of Greenland, Oceanwide and Shenzhen New World, however, even mainland developers who have stayed out of legal trouble in California have suffered setbacks.

In addition to Oceanwide’s stalled LA development, Wang Jianlin’s Dalian Wanda agreed in 2018 to sell of its One Beverly Hills project for $420 million, the same price that the Beijing-based developer had paid to acquire the site in 2014. China’s largest commercial developer never managed to break ground on its southern California dream.

Related Stories

  • Wanda Sells One Beverly Hills Project for a Reported $420MWanda Sells One Beverly Hills Project for a Reported $420M
  • China Oceanwide Selling San Francisco Project at $276M LossChina Oceanwide Selling San Francisco Project at $276M Loss
  • China Oceanwide Halts Construction on $1B Los Angeles ProjectChina Oceanwide Halts Construction on $1B Los Angeles Project
  • Greenland, Oceanwide and Hazens Named in FBI Probe of LA Real Estate DealsGreenland, Oceanwide and Hazens Named in FBI Probe of LA Real Estate Deals

Share this now

  • LinkedIn
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Email

Filed Under: Outbound Investment Tagged With: California, daily-sp, Featured, Los Angeles, Shenzhen Hazens, weekly-sp

Proptech Registration Jumbo

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Yardi Vendor Cafe

Get Mingtiandi Delivered

Proptech Registration Column

Latest Stories

The building that Keppel recently sold last December

Keppel to Market Seoul Office Towers for Over $200M and More Asia Real Estate Headlines

westin sacramento3

Eagle Hospitality Trust Hotels Declare Bankruptcy as Singapore REIT Collapses

Graeme Torre APG

APG Boosts Godrej Indian Office Platform to $250M First Closing

Korea’s NPS Extends Term of CIO Ahn Hyo-joon

Allianz Fund Buys Stake in SG Tower for $477M, Picks Up Shanghai Office Complex

Sponsored Features

CK Lau

Asia Pacific Logistics Sector: Increasingly Varied Sector Requires Multiple Approaches Sponsored Feature

COVID-19 Uncertainty Creates New Priorities for Real Estate Investors Sponsored Feature

Urban planning

Urban Placemaking with Big Data and Little People Sponsored Feature

Hines’ One Museum Place Celebrates One Year of a New Shanghai Landmark Sponsored Feature

More Sponsored Features>>

MTD-QR-Code-320

Top Stories

Allianz Fund Buys Stake in SG Tower for $477M, Picks Up Shanghai Office ComplexAllianz Fund Buys Stake in SG Tower for $477M, Picks Up Shanghai Office Complex

Tech Adoption in Asian Real Estate: Download the ReportTech Adoption in Asian Real Estate: Download the Report

Shanghai Core Office Rents Fell 6.7% Last Year as Vacancy ClimbsShanghai Core Office Rents Fell 6.7% Last Year as Vacancy Climbs

Tishman Speyer Promotes Wilson Chen to CEO of China BusinessTishman Speyer Promotes Wilson Chen to CEO of China Business


Connect with Mingtiandi

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Real Estate News

  • Capital Markets
  • Events
    • Join the Mingtiandi Proptech Forum 2021
      • Asia Proptech 2021: COVID-19 Accelerates a Trend
      • Panel Talk: Tech Adoption in Logistics Real Estate
    • Promote Your Brand with the Mingtiandi Proptech Forum 2021
    • 2021 Mingtiandi Event Calendar
    • More Events
  • MTD TV
  • People
  • Logistics
  • Asia Outbound
  • Retail
  • Design & Construction
  • Research & Policy
  • Advertise

More Mingtiandi

  • About Mingtiandi
  • Contact Mingtiandi
  • Newsletter Subscription
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy
  • Advertise
  • Join the Mingtiandi Team

We use cookies in accordance with our Privacy policy to provide the best user experience on Mingtiandi and to safeguard user data. By continuing to browse you consent to the policy. AcceptRefuse