Mingtiandi

Asia real estate and outbound investment news

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
Sign Up / Login Logout

Lost your password?
Register
Forgotten Password
Cancel

Register For This Site

A password will be e-mailed to you.

  • Capital Markets
  • Events
    • Mingtiandi 2023 Event Calendar
    • Mingtiandi APAC Residential Forum 2023
    • Mingtiandi Asia Logistics Forum 2023
    • Mingtiandi Hong Kong Focus Forum 2023
    • Mingtiandi APAC Data Centre Forum 2023
    • Mingtiandi Asia Office Strategies Forum 2023
    • Mingtiandi Singapore Focus Forum 2023
    • More Events
  • MTD TV
  • People
  • Logistics
  • Data Centres
  • Asia Outbound
  • Retail
  • Research & Policy
  • Advertise

PAG Demands Legal Action as REIT Goes Rogue

2017/11/01 by Greg Isaacson Leave a Comment

PAG Real Estate’s Broderick Storie isn’t buying Spring REIT’s claims

A feud between a Hong Kong-listed real estate investment trust and one its biggest unit holders is ramping up, with alternative investment manager PAG demanding action by Hong Kong regulators over what it deems to be misleading statements by the management of Hong Kong-listed Spring REIT.

PAG Real Estate has written to Hong Kong’s Securities & Futures Commission (SFC) and the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong (SEHK) to demand “appropriate action” against Spring REIT over a recent circular announcing the REIT’s upcoming extraordinary general meeting, according to an announcement today.

Hong Kong-based PAG is waging a campaign to “save” Spring REIT, after the trust manager decided to mix in a chain of 84 UK auto repair shops with its portfolio of premium office assets in Beijing. The escalating feud has seen PAG call for a meeting to vote on changing Spring REIT’s management in August, among other measures it said were necessary to boost the performance of the flagging REIT.

Investor Calls Out REIT Manager

“The letter submits that the Manager has presented material inaccuracies which are detrimental to the interests of Spring REIT unitholders and which could prevent unitholders from making properly informed voting decisions,” according to the PAG statement.

The statement refers to Spring REIT’s circular filed with the Hong Kong exchange on October 25th, announcing the upcoming meeting on November 10th. PAG alleges that the REIT failed to disclose potential conflicts of interest and offered implausible excuses for keeping Spring REIT’s manager in place.

“The practical objections that the management of Spring REIT has thrown at unitholders over their potential removal is a case of making mountains out of molehills,” commented Broderick Storie, partner and managing director with PAG Real Estate in the statement. “The hurdles raised are easily overcome and, in our experience, do not amount to insurmountable challenges.”

PAG’s investment vehicles collectively hold around 12.5 percent of the issued units of Spring REIT.

Spring REIT Responds to PAG Request

Kwik Fit UK

Spring REIT felt that a portfolio of UK auto repair shops would nicely complement its prime Beijing office towers

PAG Real Estate’s dissatisfaction with the REIT first made headlines on August 29, when it called for an extraordinary general meeting to vote on four proposals: to remove Spring REIT’s manager; internalise the management function; appoint Storie as a non-executive director; and appoint independent experts to review the REIT’s strategy, performance and governance.

In its October circular, Spring REIT’s manager advised against the first two of these proposed resolutions, rejecting PAG’s arguments and saying that the removal of the manager could trigger a loan default and create problems with finding replacement property management staff. (These points are summarized in an accompanying announcement.)

The second resolution, to internalise management of the REIT, would only be considered if the resolution to remove the REIT’s manager were passed, according to the circular. Spring REIT also blocked consideration of PAG’s third and fourth proposals, saying they will be tabled and considered at a future extraordinary general meeting only if the second resolution is passed.

“The Manager has received written confirmations from certain Unitholders (whose unitholdings in aggregate represent more than 50% of the voting rights of Spring REIT as at the Latest Practicable Date) stating that: (i) they are satisfied with the performance of the Manager in managing Spring REIT; (ii) have no intention to support any proposal to remove the Manager; and (iii) intend to vote against the First Request if proposed at an extraordinary general meeting of Unitholders,” according to the statement.

PAG Fires Back at REIT Statement

In its response, PAG points out that Spring REIT’s manager did not specify which entities it was referring to in claiming that “certain Unitholders” were happy with the manager’s performance. Of particular concern for PAG, the REIT’s statement fails to mention that at least 34 percent of Spring REIT’s units are controlled by the manager and what PAG deems to be “friendly parties.”

Tokyo-listed Mercuria Investment Co owns 90.2 percent of Spring REIT’s manager. According to PAG, 36 percent of Mercuria’s revenue comes from its management fees for Spring REIT, on which the company reaps a 62.3 percent profit margin. “It is therefore no surprise that they are saying they will use their units in Spring REIT to vote to lock themselves in as the Manager,” according to PAG.

PAG also rejects the REIT’s arguments about the technical hurdles to changing Spring REIT’s manager and moving to an internal management structure, saying there should be no issues with extending the current loan facility, seeking refinancing, or finding a replacement property management provider.

Moreover, PAG is irked by the manager’s apparent indifference to Spring REIT’s underperforming unit price and 45 discount to net asset value. “The huge discount to NAV is a real impost that all unitholders have suffered and cannot just be wished away as an inconvenient performance measure,” commented Storie. “The Manager continues to resist sensible and proven suggestions to unlock this value,” he added.

Car Shop Acquisition Raises Conflict of Interest Questions

Up until this year, Spring REIT’s portfolio consisted of a pair of prime office towers in Beijing’s China Central Place, covering 120,245 square metres, as well as 600 parking spaces. The REIT aroused PAG’s ire when – in a radical change of strategy – it bought a portfolio of car servicing centres leased to the Kwik-Fit brand in the UK suburbs for $93.3 million. The transaction completed in July marked the largest property investment by a Hong Kong REIT outside of Greater China.

Spring REIT is managed by Spring Asset Management Limited, a Hong Kong-incorporated subsidiary of Mercuria. Japan’s Itochu holds a 19.5 percent stake in Mercuria, along with having acquired a 100 percent interest in the Kwik-Fit Group in 2011.

Share this now

  • LinkedIn
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Email

Filed Under: Finance Tagged With: daily-sp, Featured, Hong Kong stock exchange, PAG, Spring REIT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Mingtiandi Delivered

MTD TV

PDG Says Ready for Competition in Asia Hyperscale Market: MTD TV
Japan Logistics Panel
Japan Logistics Offers a Safe Haven During a Bumpy 2022: MTD TV

More MTD TV Videos>>

People in the News

Johnny Shao CPE
Asia Real Estate People in the News 2023-03-27
Jonathan Yap CapitaLand
Jonathan Yap Named CapitaLand Development CEO as Leow Retires Early
Grace Woo Chia-ching, executive director of CK Asset (Getty Images)
Asia Real Estate People in the News 2023-03-20
Eugene Kohn KPF
Asia Real Estate People in the News 2023-03-13

More Industry Professionals>>

People in the News

Asia Real Estate People in the News 2023-03-27

Johnny Shao CPE

Top level moves at European and Asian fund managers lead this week’s list of personnel changes from around Asia Pacific … Read More>>

Jonathan Yap Named CapitaLand Development CEO as Leow Retires Early

Jonathan Yap CapitaLand

Singapore property giant CapitaLand on Thursday announced the upcoming retirement of CapitaLand Development CEO Jason … Read More>>

Asia Real Estate People in the News 2023-03-20

Grace Woo Chia-ching, executive director of CK Asset (Getty Images)

Senior changes at developers in Hong Kong and mainland China lead this week’s review of personnel changes in Asia, with … Read More>>

Asia Real Estate People in the News 2023-03-13

Eugene Kohn KPF

The passing of a global architecture giant leads this week’s round of personnel updates on Mingtiandi, as KPF mourns the … Read More>>

More Industry Professionals>>

Latest Stories

5 Churchill Place
China’s Cheung Kei Scrambling to Sell London Office Assets as Debt Deadline Looms 
Chen Hongtian of Cheung Kei
Creditors Seize Cheung Kei Hong Kong HQ, Chairman’s Luxury Homes
Lofter auction
Lofter, SC Capital Win Full Control of Ap Lei Chau Site With $20M Compulsory Sale

Sponsored Features

TE Capital's Solitaire on Cecil
Pair of Floors Sold as TE Capital, LaSalle Launch Cecil Street Office Tower in Singapore
What Do Real Estate Investors Really Want?
Douglas Wu of Fairland
Fairland Creates Spark City Lifestyle Hub to Energise Hong Kong’s Cheung Sha Wan

More Sponsored Features>>

Connect with Mingtiandi

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Real Estate News

  • Capital Markets
  • 2022 Event Calendar
  • MTD TV Archives
  • People
  • Logistics
  • Data Centres
  • Asia Outbound
  • Retail

More Mingtiandi

  • About Mingtiandi
  • Contact Mingtiandi
  • Mingtiandi Membership
  • Newsletter Subscription
  • Advertise
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy
  • Join the Mingtiandi Team


© 2007-2023 China Advertising Media Ltd (Samoa). All rights reserved.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.